I see a couple of things you could should try before giving up on the poly.
Polyurethane alternative floor reddit.
This polyurethane alternative is essentially a plant based oil combined with a natural hardener.
You should see a fine white powder after sanding if not allow it to dry longer between coats.
Two coats are sufficient for polyurethane but you can add one or two more.
Thin full strength poly 1 1 with mineral spirits or naptha i like naptha because it flashes very quickly speeding up dry times and reducing the window of time in which dust can settle and apply with a rag instead of a brush.
Polyurethane and also on minwax stain.
I actually like oak grain on a floor especially an old floor like mine.
In order to help you distinguish the differences between each one this article discusses some of these finishes.
Developed in 1937 by i g.
Sand polyurethane lightly between coats with 220 or higher grit sandpaper.
Farbin these materials were used to create gum rubbers rigid foam and elastomers.
So anyway those are my thoughts on waterlox vs.
A polyurethane coating or urethane floor coating is a highly flexible highly abrasion resistant floor coating that is known for its shine and longevity.
Shellac is a clear gloss finish that comes from the secretion of an insect and is mixed with alcohol.
We recommend using hard varnish for cabinetry architraves floors.
The hardener is responsible for the durable finish.
Polyurethane and varnish vs.
If you have your own waterlox vs.